This book has actually changed ratings for me since I’ve gotten some distance from it. I have it sitting at five stars, but looking back I think it was just an extremely good four star read. The most amazing thing about it was how the author made science so accessible from engineering to astronomy, I never felt bogged down in technical detail and actually wanted to learn more on those topics. What this book lacks is, well, characters. Am I the only one that feels like this was an action driven novel with very little action? After all a lot of what Mark does is wait. Still, the goofy tone he took in be-bopping around Mars by himself kept me reading as well.
I loved the accessibility as well. I didn’t read this until recently because I thought the science would bore me to tears. Nope. There were a few teensy areas where I found myself drifting but for the most part I was right there with Mark with my fingers firmly crossed for his survival.
I know, Neil, I don’t get the hype either. Like April said, no real characters and no real action, but it pushed the book into unenjoyable territory for me. I just never felt nervous for Mark at all. It actually shocks me that so many people talk about staying up late and being on the edge of their seat the whole time they were reading, because I never felt he was in danger. How could Andy Weir introduce one ridiculously likable character (so cheery that I found him grating by the midpoint of the novel) and then kill him off? Or even seriously injure him? And Mark, if you’re really scared, can you show it? I mean, I know this hokey bit is your thing, but where’s the emotion? YOU ARE STUCK ON MARS.
So, I was bored and didn’t buy it. The book became a series of repetitive treks across Mars that followed the same rise and fall in action with really awful dialogue from NASA on Earth to boot. Phew, Mark’s safe! Science, potatoes.
Of course there was danger! He was stranded. On Mars! I knew he wasn’t going to be killed off from the beginning, but I think I wasn’t sure if he was going to get back home, or be stuck there forever, or what. Was “The Martian” referring to him as a temporary or a permanent Martian? Or maybe he’d meet a Martian! (It is sci-fi, after all). Those are the kind of things that kept me on the edge of my seat and up all night.
I didn’t know whether he was going to make it off Mars alive. I had no idea. I’m not kidding when I say that I could feel my heart POUNDING during the last pages. I don’t know if that has ever happened to me before? I put my hand on my chest and feel my heart galloping away.
Shannon, you are tough! Bored?! I did read almost all the way through. He’s stuck on a hostile environment and the smallest of things can decimate his chances of getting home. Like the airlock fabric ripping. Suddenly, no food, no shelter. He’s on the edge of starvation. When I think of bored in a futuristic sense I think of Michel Faber’s The Book of Strange New Things. That guy had nothing to worry about. And Jennifer, I was the same way. I was gripping the book so tightly I almost shredded it.
I was okay with it not being an intense read. And I totally agree there was a silly, hokey side to it. It worked for me for the same reasons in the same way I loved watching Red Dwarf. It was entertaining, funny, and even campy, and still satisfied the geek in me. (The silliness of the NASA guys was the only part that annoyed me, because it was so outside how I think they’d ever behave in that situation).
I thought the goofy humor was fabulous. Especially from Mark. His humor kept him alive. Plus, I always like a smart ass character. Maybe I’ve seen Apollo 13 too many times but the scientists were annoying in a way that felt very real- I mean have you ever dealt with IT people?! Rude zoomers. And I agree, Monika, it may not have been intense (too much science talk for that) but it was exactly as it should be to make a great read.
Did you really feel like you got a sense of Mark as a character, though? I feel like we don’t really know anything about him beyond his quirky jokes and his skillset, which would be fine, but he also doesn’t show a very wide range of emotions (especially for being stranded on Mars). After a whole book alone in Mark’s head, we don’t know him much better than when we started. There was a chance for at least a few moments of real emotion, but Weir wrote him with almost no family or loved ones back home. It all just lacks depth.
I actually find the movie trailer much more appealing (and even thought I would prefer a movie when I wrote my review) because it seems to address these problems. In just the few minutes of the trailer we see more emotion from Mark than the whole of the book: we see him breaking down, reaching out to a screen, etc.
Maybe you were craving more literary sci-fi, along the lines of Mary Doria Russell’s The Sparrow?
I’m not sure. I don’t want to make this sound like I need every book to have countless themes or make me take twenty pages of notes, but I just found it predictable in pretty much every way. I’ll be over here eating Mark’s potatoes in my corner of the internet on this one: population 1! (EDIT: Hear…Read This! discussed the book and there are four other people who hated it. Population 5!)
Maybe Mark wasn’t a complicated guy but I totally bought him. I thought he was hilarious and dorky and smart and adorable and is it obvious that I have a total crush? Swoon.
Read our Reviews:
Lovely Bookshelf | Steadfast Reader | River City Reading | The Gilmore Guide to Books
What do you think about The Martian, readers? Did you love riding along with Mark? Was the science too much or just enough? Did this change your perspective on sci-fi novels? How are you feeling about the movie?
July 9, 2015 at 4:25 am
First of all, Shannon, I feel for you. I know how annoyed I get when everyone is raving about a book I just don’t get. It usually makes me like the book even less the more I hear people gush about it. (Sorry, books. I know it’s not your fault.)
That said, count me among the gushers for this one! I thought it was great. It was so much fun, and so intense. The earlier perils, sure, you know Mark’s going to make it through (but how?!), but I honestly thought he might die in the final pages. A part of me wonders if I’d have liked that book even better; all that “isn’t life wonderful?” optimism did sort of make the ending feel a bit hokey.
If there’s one thing I didn’t like as much (and maybe the only thing keeping this from a 5-star book for me) is the fact that it felt like a lot of the NASA characters had the same snarkiness and wit that Mark did, and it made me feel like all of these characters had Andy Weir’s voice instead of their own.
But that was a minor thing for me. I totally bought Mark as a character, even if we didn’t get a wide range of emotion. He has to keep things light. Exactly like Catherine says, it keeps him alive. I got the sense throughout that this was just one side of Mark, the one he’s putting out as his public front (especially once he does establish contact and knows he’s not just talking to himself), and it’s one that he’s desperately clinging to so he doesn’t lose it out there. When you’re the first person to be alone on an entire planet, I imagine it wouldn’t take much to just give up and let the end come… and then we wouldn’t have a story. I might feel differently if his sections were told in third person, but then that would have been a different book (though, I suspect, one more to Shannon’s liking).
LikeLike
July 9, 2015 at 9:11 am
I never thought about whether or not I would have liked it if it was written in third person, but I definitely think not having Mark’s voice would have moved it up a few notches. Actually, even having a few different perspectives, like the people on the ship that left him behind, could have mixed things up enough that it wouldn’t have felt so obnoxious.
LikeLike
July 9, 2015 at 12:28 pm
I feel like, in addition to just being a different voice, it would have opened up more possibilities for introspection… as weird as that is to say. Usually it’s the other way around with 1st/3rd, but like I said, I feel like the epistolary format changes that.
LikeLike
July 12, 2015 at 8:51 am
I think it actually WOULD have been more interesting that way as well.
LikeLike
July 9, 2015 at 6:08 am
Shannon’s comments make me feel okay about giving this one a miss. I was afraid I would find it boring and now I’m pretty sure I would. Maybe the movie will be better though!
LikeLike
July 9, 2015 at 9:01 am
While I was entertained by this book, I’m in Shannon’s camp where Mark’s humor grated on me by the end. I never felt his utter isolation on Mars and the dire urgency/hopelessness of his situation. Also, the suspense was ruined for me in the book’s format. Since it’s Mark’s diary, we already know he got out of xyz predicament. The telling vs. showing makes me think this will be a mich better movie.
LikeLike
July 9, 2015 at 12:46 pm
I think since it went into a 3rd person perspective for the final sequence, that really increased the urgency, even if it was lacking earlier in the book. Maybe I’m naive, but I really did think Weir could kill him off in that final escape attempt.
LikeLike
July 9, 2015 at 3:32 pm
No! It definitely picked up at the end there when they were figuring out how to get him back. But I figured he’d make it through—it just felt too lighthearted throughout for Mark to die.
LikeLike
July 10, 2015 at 7:24 am
The telling (combined with the lack of concern) is what made it so dull for me. I definitely think it will be more enjoyable and intense to watch.
LikeLike
July 9, 2015 at 9:07 am
Let it be known that I ALSO hated The Book of Strange New Things (zzzzzzzz). Here, everyone, have a copy of The Sparrow.
LikeLike
July 9, 2015 at 9:15 am
Second. Started it on audio and didn’t even get half-way through. Total snoozer.
LikeLike
July 11, 2015 at 8:06 pm
No argument there. I thought it was boring but The Martian struck me as the exact opposite. In Strange New Things I was more interested in Earth than I was in the other planet.
LikeLike
July 9, 2015 at 9:19 am
Oh, how I love this post/argument. I adored The Martian and every sciencey, sweary, pop-culture-referencing, ulcer-inducing minute of it. Dude was a PRO stuck on MARS, if he panicked he would be dead. I don’t want to know about his family back home or what his life is like, all I care about is how and if he’s going to get back to planet Earth. And I wasn’t all too convinced Weir wasn’t going to kill him off.
Shannon, that gif kills me, I’m so going to miss you when we pack up your corner, pop. 4, and send you off to Mars. (Oh, I do love a good book “argument.”) 🙂
LikeLike
July 10, 2015 at 7:24 am
It’s so lonely here.
LikeLike
July 10, 2015 at 6:54 pm
Bet you’re sick of potatoes, too.
LikeLike
July 12, 2015 at 8:49 am
I almost spit out my tea on my computer. 🙂
LikeLike
July 9, 2015 at 9:50 am
Okay, I was totally going to pass this one by, but now I am too intrigued! When I’ll get to read it, I have no idea, but it is now on my TBR list!! 🙂 I love it when their is disagreement regarding ratings/opinions and when people express themselves so respectfully! Thank you for that! 🙂
LikeLike
July 11, 2015 at 9:34 am
I hope that you read it and I hope that you love it as much as some of us did 😉
LikeLike
July 11, 2015 at 8:00 pm
You could wait and read it this fall before the movie comes out in October and then come back when we all corral about whether the book or movie was better!
LikeLike
July 12, 2015 at 10:52 am
That is a fantastic idea, Catherine! I’ll aim for that!
LikeLike
July 12, 2015 at 8:50 am
We try to be champions of respectful disagreement here. 🙂
LikeLike
July 12, 2015 at 10:51 am
And that “respectful disagreement” is what I love about this post and these discussions! I always aim for respect in all my reviews and discussions about books (or anything else, for that matter). We all have opinions and they all differ and that is what makes life so interesting!! Thanks to you all for presenting such a good example! 🙂
LikeLike
July 9, 2015 at 10:45 am
I have to say I really enjoyed it though I thought I wouldn’t. I agree Mark wasn’t the most well rounded of characters but I liked him so didn’t mind. Of course, I might think differently if I normally read sci-fi but as I don’t I would definitely say it was a good read.
LikeLike
July 9, 2015 at 11:52 am
I really enjoyed it. It actually became my go to recommendation last year. I felt this was a book almost anyone could enjoy. Young adult, mother in law, hubby who doesn’t read much, this book, I felt, fit everyone. There are so few books I feel I can recommend to serious readers, non readers and the person I don’t really know their tastes but asks if I’ve read any good books lately. Maybe because it’s not to deep, it’s light, fun and just far enough out there, to be something different for most people.
LikeLike
July 9, 2015 at 12:48 pm
My husband is an engineer and I knew he would love this book (which he did). All the “science the shit out of this” stuff was right up his alley.
LikeLike
July 9, 2015 at 1:11 pm
Funny, mine is also an engineer (chemical) and he rarely reads fiction but I pushed this one on him and he loved it!
LikeLike
July 9, 2015 at 12:04 pm
To go a totally different direction, April stated the book has changed star rating for her after time. I find that happens a lot with me. I might struggle with a book and not really love it, then months later when I’m still thinking about the book or its characters, wonder does it deserve a higher rating, it’s obviously stuck with me and made me think. Or the opposite, loving it during the read, then realizing all the flaws in it after I’ve really thought about it? I also look back at books from years and years ago and think wow, compared to what I’ve read since then, that 4 star book doesn’t compare to the books I rate 4 stars now. Also after talking to people. You don’t even want to know how many times my book club had changed my mind, in both directions, about a book we are discussing. When really is the best time to rate a book? Right away, a week later, a month? Time will always have an affect on ratings as our life and perspectives will always be changing. Sorry to go off on a tangent, Aprils statement just hit home.
LikeLike
July 9, 2015 at 12:54 pm
I’m always a fan of a good tangent.
This happens to me quite a bit. Personally, the way I use ratings is to express how much I enjoyed the book, not necessarily if the book is “good,” so it makes sense to rate it right away as a sort of gut reaction. If I’m already second-guessing myself after sleeping on it, I might change it the next day. But past that, I won’t change a rating unless/until I re-read the book (which I’ve done on several occasions).
Discussions like this one might make me think more about the strengths and weaknesses in the book itself, but suddenly seeing things wrong with it doesn’t mean it wasn’t enjoyable to read.
LikeLike
July 10, 2015 at 9:24 am
This is a great tangent – maybe we need to make it a whole post!
LikeLike
July 12, 2015 at 8:49 am
SECONDED. 🙂
LikeLike
July 9, 2015 at 12:51 pm
What impressed me most about this book was how smart it was. It kind of made up for any flaws I thought the book had. I kept thinking there was no way around certain obstacles, but he always found a way and it was always explained to my satisfaction. I didn’t get it all, but I did get that it wasn’t made up out of thin air. It also makes me curious to see what this guy’s going to come up with next.
LikeLike
July 9, 2015 at 9:13 pm
That’s exactly how I felt about it!
LikeLike
July 11, 2015 at 8:04 pm
I felt the same way, Naomi. I almost wanted a glossary of terms! And then I felt like I was learning stuff even when I was being so completely entertained.
LikeLike
July 9, 2015 at 2:09 pm
I read this a few months back I didn’t think I was going to like it as much as I did! My friend’s husband suggested this to me. I found it really fun and hilarious! I had a feeling he would survive someway and I really enjoyed him & his entries. It was a quick read & just a fun ride!
LikeLike
July 9, 2015 at 2:38 pm
I grudgingly picked this one up thinking I wouldn’t like it, but ended up really liking it. I loved Mark’s humor…especially when he makes fun of NASA. And, I think the book addressed his personality to some extent when it talked about the fact that each team is put together for specific psychological/personality reasons (in addition to hard skillsets)…and that Mark was basically the “humor guy”.
I was in the “on the edge of my seat” camp as far as the suspense. I figured he’d make it back, but the big unknown for me was how. And – it’s been awhile since I read it, but doesn’t the book end before the capsule actually makes it back to Earth?! Mark is safely inside, but there are still some major risk factors at play that could make the capsule not actually make it to Earth?
Finally – did anyone else get a Hunger Games feeling from the whole “the world is watching and rooting for you, Mark” thing? I really loved that whole dynamic of this being a massive news story that was playing out live back on Earth. But, like Shannon, I would have enjoyed hearing more about Mark’s life back home and think it could have worked well in the “everyone is watching” part of the story (i.e. what’s his family doing while they watch?!). Of course, this never occurred to me when I was actually reading…just now that you mention it…ha!
LikeLike
July 9, 2015 at 4:32 pm
I didn’t get the Hunger Games feel, but I agree on wanting a little more of his home life and what was going through their minds, their emotions, etc. at Mark being stuck on Mars. I was really surprised at what little dialog there seemed to be (it was pretty much mission control), but I guess that’s because it was Mark’s logs and written much like a memoir.
LikeLike
July 9, 2015 at 4:29 pm
I finished the audiobook and loved it, but I’m not so sure that I would have loved it the same way had I read a print copy. I wonder if I was more in love with the narrator than the story, but it still kept me interested, so I gave it 4 stars. I wasn’t on the edge of my seat at all and didn’t feel the story was intense until the end when everything had caught up to Mark, but on the rescue, I just wanted to pledge my allegiance to flag and give a standing ovation. The science was pretty spot on and not over the top because it was as if I was inside Mark’s mind as he was working through ideas based on his knowledge. I did get a little emotional when he was telling whoever read his logs to take care of his mother. *sniff* In all honesty, I felt like Mark was telling his story to me directly for most of the time or as I said, I was inside of his mind with a front row seat.
Side note: The audiobook was phenomenal!
LikeLike
July 11, 2015 at 9:36 am
I keep hearing about how awesome the audio of this book was. One of these days… Mark is one of the best narrators ever, isn’t he? Ooh I just loved his “voice”. I hope the movie does the book justice.
LikeLike
July 11, 2015 at 4:11 pm
The audiobook was phenomenal, Jennifer! The audio narrator was R.C. Bray, and his expressions and pitch really made the book stand out for me.
LikeLike
July 12, 2015 at 8:51 am
I’m in an audiobook re-reading extravaganza (because of my new commute and new job leaving me exhausted) – I may have to check it out 🙂
LikeLike
July 13, 2015 at 6:24 pm
Oh, you should! You’ll find yourself walking into work and home laughing out loud until you reach the intense parts. But the expression of the reader! Amazing. It’s my favorite audiobook as far as speakers go, moving The Help into second place.
LikeLike
July 12, 2015 at 8:55 am
Hahaha… I just re-read my review and I enjoyed the line, “The only thing sci-fi about this book is Americans using the metric system.” 🙂
LikeLike
July 17, 2015 at 1:20 pm
I just finished this last night. I thoroughly enjoyed it! I loved Mark’s character, and I think part of that is I started with the audiobook, and the narrator was fantastic (as Mark – I went Kindle about 25% of the way through). Yes, it was a little campy and nobody has that kind of luck, but it was a fun story. It definitely appealed to my current obsession with all things interplanetary this summer. I can relate to Jennifer and Catherine – those last pages were intense.
LikeLike
July 19, 2015 at 11:14 pm
I’m with Jennifer – I loved Mark! And although I wasn’t ever worried he’d die, I was constantly curious to see how he’d survive each new disaster. Even in retrospect, this is a solid 5 stars for me 🙂
LikeLike
July 21, 2015 at 4:58 pm
I liked The Martian pretty well — the page-turning parts — but it’s also loaded with technical details, which in my opinion gets excessive at times. On the one hand, it’s great having a lot of scientific details in the novel to make it seem real, but the constant equation set-ups clogged it up at times. In places, it sort of felt like reading a textbook instead of an action thriller. My mind fuzzed over some of the scientific and math thought processes, and the middle of the book sagged for me, as Watney carried out a lot of tests for his proposed rescue plans.
But luckily “The Martian” picks up towards the end. And how it all plays out is worth sticking around for. I imagine the movie of it with Matt Damon could be quite riveting.
LikeLike